Thursday, January 29, 2009

The French layout challenge


What you see here is a kinda complicated French sawhorse. At first glance, it may appear ridiculous to some - what possible point can there be in constructing such an object?

Strictly speaking, as far as sawhorse 'requirements' are concerned, this unit is clearly beyond any performance need. As the description for the piece reads, it is "très résistant". Much more than that though, this sawhorse is a vehicle for study of roof layout, particularly the layout of hipped roofs with diagonal bracing. As an example of roofwork featuring this sort of bracing, I attach a picture of one application, a Mansard roof:
There's more to this sawhorse than meets the eye at first. Take a look at the legs. You will see that one pair, diagonally opposed, are rotated so the corner of the leg meets the corner of the floor plan of the horse, and the other two legs are rotated 45˚ along their axes, similar to the way a hip rafter is commonly oriented (i.e., the side of the rafter is aligned plumb to the floor). Even the pair that are rotated so their corners meet the floor are subtly different from one another - one being aligned to the long axis of the plan, and the other aligned to the short axis. To this melange of leg orientations, we interconnect x-braces, and then even inter-connect x-braces between cross braces. It's quite insane! I get dizzy just looking at it. The layout problem condenses into determining relationships of positions between parts, as there isn't wiggle room between pieces, with so many crowded into the same space. To complicate it further, the pieces are all through-tenoned to each other, which means the shapes of the tenons vary and the mortises are shaped to suit. Even the cut out of the mortises will be difficult, given their shapes.

Why tackle something like this? Can I sell it for big bucks? I doubt it, and that is most certainly not the point. While some may question the value of doing anything if there isn't a pot of gold at the end, the study of this sawhorse, and the successful incorporation of the layout technique into my repertoire will lead to something quite wonderful: to be able join a piece of wood, at any rotation and orientation, to another piece of wood, at any orientation or rotation. This is a powerful possibility, and opens up wide design possibilities, as does any new capability. There is endless material that can be studied through the 'vehicle' of the sawhorse, and I will cover versions of Japanese sawhorses, which are complex in a different way, in subsequent posts.

I want to make this sawhorse, but I can't make it yet. Despite nearly a hundred hours of study, and multiple re-draws, I still do not understand this sawhorse completely. I'm getting there though, and expect to get to the construction phase within a month. Then I expect that the first time I make it there will be some goof-up, something I didn't see quite understand. If I don't understand a drawing, then I draw it again and again until the truth is gradually revealed. If I make it and something doesn't fit right, then I make it again until everything fits. It's a bit of a 'brute force and ignorance approach', more dependent upon perspiration than inspiration, but that is how it goes sometimes. Sometimes I wake up in the morning suddenly understanding what was a mystery the night before.

Here's what the drawing looked like a while back, to give you an idea of what is involved in determining the cut lines for each piece. This drawing is about 80% complete, and has a few problems, so I will be drawing it again. I need to rest a while and let some stuff soak in. I'm also in communication with a campagnon du devoir to help understand some of the, er, 'sticking points'. Not the best pun, but worth a try, no?

If you click on the drawing, it will become a bit larger and clearer. Welcome to my dream.



Okay - interested in reading about the actual build?

Go to part I


Want to skip the build and see how it turned out in the end? Click here.

For the next post on the subject of French carpentry in general, click here.

6 comments:

  1. Great posts so far. I think you'll really get on a roll here. My biggest problem is I have a lot of trouble putting pictures where I want them in the text but others don't seem to have this problem. Keep up the great work. I turned to this because I never had the software to change my web site and this was just easier.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Very cool and interesting, I hope to one day see you take a crack at it, full scale or not. Let me know if you ever require French to English translation, I would gladly assist there. Keep up the great content

    ReplyDelete
  3. Yes, I'm feeling on a roll!

    Neda, thanks for the offer about the translation. It's been quite a struggle trying to work out 19th century French. I gave a couple of pages out of the text to a French Canadian student I had a couple of years back, and he really found it hard to translate. I speaking with another fellow just yesterday in fact concerning the difficult French. He said he only considers the drawings, and when he showed some of the text to a French lawyer one time, the fellow could hardly make head or tail of it. I'm helped a bit by having a French-English dictionary from 1903, on loan from my landlady, and it get's easier with time. The book does have an extensive glossary, which I have been translating - so far I'm up to 'D'. I'll let you know if I have any questions. And don't worry- I will definitely be taking a crack at building the sawhorse soon.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Nice sawhorse, challengingly complex. I pass, but I hope you will succeed. Is it further described with other drawings? I see for example tenon joints only for the two x-braces inside. My guess is that al the rest is made with some sort of shouldered lap joint. And are the right legs not curved?

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi Damian,

    I will succeed in making this sawhorse, and plan to detail the first build attempt in the blog. Now that I've conquered the drawing, the making part is relatively straightforward though I certain have a bit more exploring to do as of yet.

    "Is it further described with other drawings?" No, the perspective elevation and developed plan view are all the book provides, and indeed a good portion of the plan view lines are eliminated simply for clarity.

    "I see for example tenon joints only for the two x-braces inside. My guess is that all the rest is made with some sort of shouldered lap joint."

    Hmm, well most of the joints are through tenons actually, though there are a few exceptions where the tenons do not go all the way though, such as where a 'barbe' from a crossing piece would be located in the same place as where the tenon would emerge. I don't believe that shouldered half laps are employed however and the joints are not housed. Some of this material will not really be clear actually until i try to assemble it, however some of the detail should wring out when the drawing is fully completed.

    "And are the right legs not curved?"

    No, all the legs are straight - thank god(!)

    Thanks for your comment- I hope you like the upcoming build on this piece, as it should be fun!

    ~Chris

    ReplyDelete
  6. Oops! sorry to mis-spell your name Damien. it was a typo i didn't catch before posting and naturally saw it immediately afterwards.

    ~Chris

    ReplyDelete

All comments are moderated, so if you're planning to spam this, know now that your clicking and pasting is in vain. I do read the comments before posting, so your mission is doomed from the outset. All this time and effort trying to put your inane spam onto blogs -- is this how you want to spend your time on earth?

Please do me the courtesy of appending your name to your comment, even if posting under the 'anonymous' option. No name = deleted.

Comments NOT accepted include:

-those containing links unrelated to blog content
-spam of any kind, or ham for that matter
-did I mention that attempted spam postings will be non-starters?